July 05, 2004
London's Burning
Well, not really, but I just can't pass up these Clash references.
I've been planning on writing a big post to address all the shit that has come up in London but after talking to many of the bloggers who are on board, and reading the comments of many who aren't I've decided it's not really worth it. The people who get it, really get it and I'm psyched that they are involved, the people who don't, probably won't, so it's not worth trying to explain.
I'm being told that the lemonade I'm making is the worst tasting milkshake ever. Well, it's not a milkshake. Some people are convinced it is, and won't shut up about how bad it is. They are all "Check out how crappy this milkshake is - there's not even MILK in it!" and I'm like "That's because it's L E M O N A D E, not a milkshake" and their reply is "You idiot, you can't make a milkshake without milk! Hahaha Silly Americans."
So what is there to say?
I don't expect every single person to "get it" right away, but basically we're not doing anything that ANYONE else has ever done, so comparisons against other sites, and what other people are doing are useless - as that isn't the plan. You never hear that some guys blogspot page has low "quality control" because it's just one guy. He's the end all be all of that page. Yet the second you get a few bloggers together some people assume there has to be editors, and direction, and whatever else you would most likely find at a magazine. But this is a BLOG. We are Bloggers, and that's that how this works.
Ask any of the authors on blogging.la how many times I've told them what to write about, or how to structure their posts, or anything like that. The answer is zero. We have the same one rule there as all the other sites - posts have to relate to the city. Each blogger takes that their own way and runs with it. It's not an issue of how one person says things, it's how the collective group sees the city. That's a perspective you couldn't get by just talking to one person, or even two or three.
I guess that's either something you get, or you don't.
I'm not going to even waste space addressing the other stuff because it's not even based in fact. I'm just laughing at the growing list of why my milkshake sucks. If anyone wants to actually *gasp* talk to me about my lemonade, I'm right here, otherwise I'm done discussing frozen dairy deserts.
Posted by sean on July 5, 2004 06:49 PM |
View blog reactions
Previous Entry:
Three new Cities
Next Entry:
Lookout Trackback Spammer
To follow your analogy, Sean, perhaps your lemonade sucks because half of the ingredients are rotten? I believe that's the point most people commenting on this issue were trying to make.
As I've said to you previously, I think the concept of a hyper-local blog is great, but maybe we Brits put a higher importance on the quality of posts? I don't think there should be censorship at an editorial level - my only point was that I can't see why, as this fellow* says, you'd want to promote a site containing laughably sub-standard blogging that turns off readers, particularly those based in London, who presumably you are trying to appeal to.
Anyway, I'm obviously no longer associated with the site and am a little embarrassed about the whole mountain/molehill, storm/teacup interface. It's only a website, innit? I just felt I should state my case, seeing how I was indirectly involved in kicking this all off. I wish you luck for the future, and hope the site can overcome these teething troubles. :)
*http://www.adam.tinworth.name/archives/2004/07/pro_bonner.html#comments
Posted by:
Smacked Face on July 6, 2004 06:03 AM
Post A Comment