seanbonnerdotcom
July 18, 2004
Bloggers aren't Journalists... Really?

Alex Jones just wrote a piece in the LA Times called "Bloggers Are the Sizzle, Not the Steak." It's the same thing we've heard a million times:

"But make no mistake, this moment of blogging legitimization — and temporary press credentials — doesn't turn bloggers into journalists."

Let me ask a question, when was the last time you heard a group of sitcom actors speaking out against talk show hosts? Chanting "just because they are on TV doesn't mean they are Actors!" Or a bunch rock bands making press statements that DJs, while they are in fact broadcast over the radio, are not in fact rock bands. Oh? Never? Maybe because that's about how stupid this sounds.

Attention all Journalists - Bloggers are NOT trying to be journalists. They are trying to be bloggers. Journalism is not blogging, blogging is not journalism. They are two different things, and reading this same drivel day after day is starting to make all these journalists sound like a bunch of insecure cry babies. Both have their own set of merits, and everyone has their own opinion as to which has more value. Blogs are getting attention because they are just that, blogs. Stop patting yourself on the back by assuming someone else is trying to be you, they aren't.

Alex goes on to say:

"With the status conferred by convention credentials, blogging has arrived as an engaging, important new player in the information carnival. But should blogging displace traditional reporting and journalism, as some in the blogosphere predict it will, then the steak will have been swapped for the sizzle. It's better to have both."

Really? Who? I know some of the most influential people in the blogosphere, some of the most well read bloggers, some of the biggest blogging advocates and none of them think that blogging will "displace traditional reporting and journalism." In fact, the only people I've ever heard say this are journalists. Do you guys know something we don't?

What it will do is put journalists in check. No more free rides, there are other sources with the info now so it's up to the journalists to stay relevant. They need to put in the effort to give us a reason to stay tuned. Maybe get back to real journalism. Take a stand on something, find the backbone that used to make journalism a respectable profession. Because until then, blogs are going to be more than happy to pick up the slack.

[Want to hear what other bloggers think? Check the this, this and this.]

Posted by sean on July 18, 2004 07:48 PM | View blog reactions
Previous Entry: Rad! Metblogs Gets Ink!
Next Entry: Cartoon Violence
Comments

Hey I've got a blog AND a degree in Journalism - can I play?

Sean I think you've hit the nail on the head - Actual People blogging Real Experiences more often than not expose "journalists" for the lazy, inaccurate fakes they truly are. It's no wonder they don't want you crashing their party.

Blog on!

Posted by: Ruth on July 18, 2004 08:49 PM

Reeking with the stench of fear, that piece. Exactly the same sort of Luddite claptrap heard from print journalists about news web sites in the mid-90s.

Bloggers aren't the only threat - there's cable TV, the booming video market, online gaming, chat rooms, MMPORGs, meetups - print journalism is not dying, it's just having a really hard time admitting it will have to adapt to survive.

Posted by: mack reed on July 18, 2004 10:02 PM

Let's not forget that Jayson Blair was a legitimate "journalist."

Posted by: Brent on July 19, 2004 06:52 AM

word.

Posted by: Sean Bonner on July 19, 2004 09:04 PM

The role of the traditional journalist is obsolete. Journalists have traditionally been experts at nothing but writing. They interview a subject-matter expert, and presumably get things more or less correct on a very shallow level.

Content isn't king. Subject matter experts are the kings and queens of the much-alleged "new journalism." If I want to read a write-up about diabetes, I don't look to my newspaper's yearly diabetes write-up assigned to a medical writer (who was on the city desk last month). I look to the American Diabetes Association site on a regular basis because this is a subject of interest to me.

Journalists are only informational middlemen. Most, but not all, bloggers share this distinction. I'll take the subject matter experts any day. I rarely see anything unique on a blog, including the blatherings above. The few blogs that consistently deal with the same subject are an exception to this rule and I believe we'll see more of that.

If I want to hear a layperson's opinion about the day's news, I'll stick to the water cooler.

Posted by: Withheld on July 20, 2004 12:49 PM

I may not be a journalist, but considering some of the crap I have seen coming from "professional journalists", spelling errors, grammatical errors, sometimes I wonder...

Posted by: Dave M. on July 20, 2004 02:04 PM

The difference between bloggers and journalists is editorial control. Bloggers write their inforomation or opinions without an editorial filter. It's more direct but it's also less controlled. That can be good (if the blogger has some discipline) or bad (if he or she is totally irresponsible about what he says and what information he provides about sources. One isn't better than the other; they're just different.

Posted by: Amy Wohl on July 20, 2004 02:45 PM

Withheld - so why are you here again?

Posted by: Sean Bonner on July 20, 2004 02:57 PM

Post A Comment

This is a single entry on a blog written by me, Sean Bonner. Please feel free to look around or even join in whatever conversation might be going on. Or don't. See if I care.

Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:









Sean Bonner has been annoying people on the internet since 1994. Currently he lives in Los Angeles and is the co-founder of Metroblogging. Despite growing up in Bradenton, Yahoo! thinks he's the most important "Sean" on the internets. He's sick of labels. This was his blog until sometime in 2007 when it broke. Check out seanbonner.com for current stuff.


+ links for 2007-10-14
+ flake
+ links for 2007-10-13
+ Right
+ links for 2007-10-12
+ Troy's Bucket
+ links for 2007-10-11
+ links for 2007-10-10
+ Arse Elektronika Photos
+ You already know how this will end

Find stuff using Technorati:

Find stuff using Google:


wiki | flickr | del.icio.us
atom | rss | rss+
archives | thanks | contact
The rules

Unless noted all content by Sean Bonner and published under a Creative Commons License

Powered by Movable Type 3.2